Argument Evaluation and Evidence by Douglas Walton

By Douglas Walton

​This monograph poses a sequence of key difficulties of evidential reasoning and argumentation. It then bargains ideas accomplished through employing lately built computational types of argumentation made to be had in synthetic intelligence. every one challenge is posed in one of these means that the answer is definitely understood. The publication progresses from confronting those difficulties and supplying suggestions to them, construction an invaluable basic process for comparing arguments alongside the best way. It presents a hands-on survey explaining to the reader how you can use present argumentation equipment and ideas which are more and more being carried out in additional targeted methods for the applying of software program instruments in computational argumentation structures. It exhibits how using those instruments and techniques calls for a brand new method of the options of data and clarification appropriate for various settings, corresponding to problems with public defense and future health, debate, criminal argumentation, forensic proof, technological know-how schooling, and using professional opinion proof in own and public deliberations.

Show description

Read or Download Argument Evaluation and Evidence PDF

Similar semantics books

Temps, aspect et modalité en français. (Cahiers Chronos)

Cet ouvrage suggest de jeter un nouveau regard sur des questions qui sont au cœur des problématiques de linguistique française étudiés dans les Cahiers Chronos. Plusieurs auteurs étudient des questions de temps et d'aspect (Apothéloz & Nowakowska, Haas & Huyghe, Lauze, Lebas-Fraczak, Moline, Provôt ; Deslés & Vinzerich) ou des emplois modaux (Engel ; Forsgren & Sullet-Nylander, Lansari, Morency, Patard & Vermeulen).

Living Words: Language, Lexicography and the Knowledge Revolution

During this choice of articles, the writer displays at the nature of language, the paintings of lexicography and the advancements in verbal exchange, the media and data know-how within the overdue twentieth century. the 3 major matters checked out are: language at huge, and particulary English, the main usual language within the background of the area; the artwork and examine of dictionaries and reference technology, embracing all previous, current and strength reference fabrics - from the "OED" to the "Yellow Pages"; and the approaches in which communique, details and information has evoloved - from cave artwork to the non-public machine.

The German Verse Epic in the Nineteenth and Twentieth Centuries

The virtually whole omit of the verse epic as a style nonetheless useful of significant dialogue and earnest research is all too obvious in German literary feedback. the one try and view the style in its evolution in the course of the centuries is Heinrich Maiworm's invaluable yet inevitably slightly perfunctory old survey of the German epic which seemed within the moment quantity of Deutsche Philologie im Auf,iss.

Cognitive Semantics and the Polish Dative

Drawing at the conceptual gear of cognitive grammar, this article goals to convey order into the array of makes use of by way of delivering a unified semantic characterization of the dative case which subsumes either "lexically ruled" and "free" datives.

Additional info for Argument Evaluation and Evidence

Sample text

Since those plants were very scarce there was one other plant called the Tribulus, which had harder and lengthier seeds so the best chance for survival was to adapt to the Tribulus and be able to eat the seeds without dying. This example is a good one for the model of explanation that will be set out in Chap. 3. 6 An Example of an Explanation in Science Education 21 asking for it. ” This transfer of understanding works by the explainer helping the explainee to fill gaps in a sequence of events and actions based as the common knowledge shared by both parties.

J. Reiser. 2008. Making sense of argumentation and explanation. Science Education 93(1): 26–55. , and L. Groarke. 1996. Toward a theory of visual argument. Argumentation and Advocacy 33(1): 1–10. C. 1932. The complete Sherlock Holmes: The memorial edition. Garden City: Doubleday, Doran & Co. M. 1995. On the acceptability of arguments and its fundamental role in nonmonotonic reasoning, logic programming and n-person games. Artificial Intelligence 77(2): 321–357. J. Hogan, and I. Stewart. 2013. An examination of the effects of argument mapping on students’ memory and comprehension performance.

It also seems to have many implications for helping us to work towards defining a defeasible notion of knowledge that could be useful for evaluating scientific reasoning based on empirical observations leading to a hypothesis. But the problem is that, for several reasons, a version of the argument is stated in a carefully circumscribed way that makes it useful only within narrow circumstances. As noted by Prakken et al. (2003, 38), Pollock’s conception of defeasible knowledge-based reasoning is based exclusively on inference rules of classical deductive logic, and inductive rules that require the use of numerical probabilities of the kinds used in statistics.

Download PDF sample

Rated 4.78 of 5 – based on 37 votes